Scenario Review

Scenario Title: 100 Years War

Author: Gary

Reviewer: Andrew Hoekzema

  Historical scenario.

A huge medieval slugfest incorporating all the major powers: England, France, Castille, Aragon, Holy Roman Empire, and the Ottomans. The French and Aragonese are battling the Catilians and English as the Holy Roman empire expands within central Europe and the Ottoman Empire makes startling victories.

Download at csc.apolyton.net

Want to be a scenario reviewer? Click here for more info.

Overall / Playability / General Care / Art & Originality / Concluding Notes

Overall Rating

23/30
COMMENTS: Map is big, about 140x140. Yearly turns from 1369-1568.

Playability Rating

9 / 10
COMMENTS: This scenario is very fun to play. I especially like being the Aragons and battling on multiple fronts. Anyone who is interested in medeival warfare should definitely check this one out. Quite challenging and very addictive.

FAULTS: Only a few major problems. The main problem is the Objectives system. It requires 50 or less for a decisive defeat, and 100 or less for a marginal defeat, and there are only 83 objectives in the entire game, and I highly doubt anyone is going to be able to take even half of those objectives. Also, I think there are some power problems. I think the French should be heavier fortified since they are caught between the British AND the Holy Roman Empire, and seemed doomed to lose. I also think that the Holy Roman Empire is too powerful in the east and that the "Other powers" should be beefed up. I played as Aragon once and captured all of North Africa save Egypt within about 15 turns. The only other thing is that the unique units are simply too powerful.

ATMOSPHERE: The atmosphere was perfect.

BALANCE: There are 6 recommended civs, I have played them all and they are all very very enjoyable.

CONCLUSIONS: I found this scenario very engrossing. There are never periods of lull in this scenario, and there are always new conflicts and skirmishes arising all over the place. Despite the few flaws I saw, I had tremendous fun with this scenario and highly endorse it.

Level of General Care

6 / 10
MAP: I think the map covers a bit too much of northern Europe such as Northeren Scandanavia, Iceland and Russia. Besides that, it serves the purposes of this scenario quite well.

DOCUMENTATION: I thought the readme was lacking, but the title text was quite explanatory. Much more could have easily have been done in terms of documentation.

TECH: The tech tree is in proper order and the tech paradigm matches fairly well the amount of techs there are to research.

DETAILS: Details are taken care of. I am not sure that I like the idea that all the other kingdoms were under the heading "other people," though. Perhaps the Arab areas should be made into barbarian run areas.

Art and Originality

8 / 10
NEW IDEAS: I thought it was a pretty cool idea to have just a big old medeival slaying festival. I liked having almost everyone being at war with each other adds a really exciting element to the scenario.

ART: Very nice artwork. The author picked very nice medeival pictures for the units and cities, and the terrain was quite nice.

NOTES: None.

 

HTML Design by Blackclove and Monk

Back to Historical Scenario Reviews