Scenario Review

Scenario Title: Aftergun

 Author: Kestrel

Reviewer: Cam Hills

  Fantasy scenario.

'Mod-pack-like' scenario offering a few spins that emphasises modern warfare.

Download Aftergun.zip from Mr. Temba's Page. (Really! It's back!)
 

Want to be a scenario reviewer? Click here for more info.

Overall / Playability / General Care / Art & Originality / Concluding Notes

Overall Rating

15/30
SYNOPSIS: The default game gets some twists, with new technologies, units, and terrains that channel the player towards modern combat.
 

Playability Rating

6/10
COMMENTS: There is nothing of note at the game's commencement. The pack contains two scenario files; aftergn5.scn and aft-ng-5.scn, although they appear to be pretty well identical. There is no detail on points of difference to guide you to one or the other. 

Seven tribes are available for selection — all from the default game with the exception of the 'Koori' tribe that is characterised by Australian regions and townships that feature the indigenous peoples' place names (Uluru, Kakadu, etc.) 

All tribes begin with a unit or two, and in most cases, a village. The map is unexplored. 

MAP: The map is a fairly regular sized 100 x 80, and achieves a workable balance of ocean and land, continents and islands. 

There are a couple of barbarian cities already placed, which may cause problems for two particular tribes in the early game. 

The comparative late arrival in the technology tree of advances leading to troop carrying sea units (the first being navigation) seriously curtails the opportunity for expansion of some of the geographically isolated tribes. 

One of the features of the map (discussed later in this review) is the large number of new terrain forms and special resources; varying jungles, scrubland, savannah, forested mountains, deer (resource), and gems (resource). 

GAME OBJECTIVE: No game objective has been set out, and as such both of the traditional objectives are retained. 

BALANCE: By-and-large this area is handled well, where there is a natural and successful progression towards more potent units. 

Some of the unit upgrades generated through Leonardo's Workshop may penalise the player if they have a lot of veterans, as the upgrades themselves in some cases are pretty inconsequential (e.g. Musketeers to Infantrymen), although this is a minor point. 

GOVERNMENT: Government switching is permitted, and really has not undergone anything too radical in the way of change. It takes an extra advance to get to Democracy (and all that flows from it), while Communism has its unit support lifted from three to four. 

 

Level of General Care

4/10
REFERENCE: Sadly this is an area in need of desperate help and is doubly important if this pack is to be used as a mod (how to install? where to install? what files should be included? sounds?). There is essentially no help, other than; 

- the unusual decision to include some brief commentary at the head of the rules.txt file, 
- the technology tree in the same file does provide pointers as to changes in structure, while 
- a separate spreadsheet is included with numerical data on units, terrain, etc. 

The ‘pedia.txt’ file is not included which would significantly reduce the difficulties associated in navigating this scenario. This is a notable omission. 

A ‘read me’ file is not included, which could have clarified lots of questions on the modifications, explained the plot / theme, and provided acknowledgement for the numerous unit and terrain graphics 'borrowed' from other scenarios. Some of the changes made were quite important to explain. For instance, the Diplomat unit does not have a 'diplomacy' role but a 'settler' role. Given its cost when compared to the Settler unit, it offers an attractive alternative, but the player would not know this unless they were to observe foreign Diplomats irrigating land or building mines. Likewise, attempts to expel foreign Diplomats obviously would be acts of war, as the player would inadvertently attack a 'settler' unit. 

'game.txt', 'labels.txt', and 'advice.txt' files are also not present, which if customised could have generated further novelty to the game. 

THEME: There does not seem to be a plot, storyline, or setting as such, with the below quote being the only commentary from the author—  

"(Aftergun) explores the diversity of units that became available after the invention of gunpowder; old unit slots recycled to make way for more units! The rule I have tried to limit myself to is to only include units which add some extra or unique characteristic; e.g. suicide squad, mortar unit, conscripts, naval artillery, poison gas." 
- Rules.txt, Aftergun 

Basically the theme is so light-on that the game really does take on a mod-pack tone. 

Unfortunately, if the feature of the package is the units that become available after gunpowder, the player must engage the game for at least half an hour (and probably longer) to encounter the first stages of this diversity. It would seem opportune to commence the game in the late-Medieval period and get straight into the action if this indeed is the game's 'strong suit'. 

OPERATION: The game did appear to work without any technical hitches, and from a playability angle, did not have any difficulties other than those already addressed. 

 

Art and Originality

5/10
GENERAL: This artwork is unfortunately largely sourced from other scenarios and credit is not given for the original works. Conversely, graphics that may be original have not been highlighted either. 

While the concept of a scenario / modpack that "explores the diversity of units that became available after the invention of gunpowder" is different, it would have benefited from greater support in the creative elements of scenario development. 

UNITS: Not surprisingly, given the author's commentary, there is an increased emphasis on artillery and missile-based units. Many of the default units are retained, many have undergone some 'tweaking' with varying degrees of success (the Alpine Troops unit has been well transformed into a Navy SEALS unit), many have been lifted from other scenarios, while there are a few that may be original (?). Shield placement is generally fine except for the very occasional unit such as the Howitzer that does suffer from shield-concealment. 

As set out in the theme explanation, there are several new units which utilise the special effects flags pretty extensively. To illustrate, the 'suicide squad' is destroyed after attacking (obviously), free support under fundamentalism, 'alpine', ignores zones of control, and can make amphibious attacks.  

TERRAIN: There have been modifications to both Terrain1.gif and Terrain2.gif, perhaps the most significant being the heavy emphasis on jungle. The varying forms of hills have been replaced by different jungle types, the hills represented by a single-image graphic only, and 'ranges' of hills no longer exist. 

New forms of terrain have been introduced (as mentioned in the 'Map' section of this review), although artistically it appears that pretty well all of the terrain images have been sourced from other games. Again, due to lack of support documentation and in particular credits for graphics sourced, the extent of 'borrowing' is uncertain. 

TECHNOLOGY: The technology tree is a strength of the game. The addition of eleven new advances (i.e. all are used) are of notable advantage. The new tech's include; automatic weapons, jungle warfare, telephone, and bayonet & infantry drill. Others have undergone a name change but offer the same general benefits as their predecessor (such as off-shore fishing for seafaring). 

Again, it is disappointing that the pedia.txt file was not included, which could better assist the player in making their technology selections. 

OTHER CREATIVE ELEMENTS: 

There are some big holes in the creative area; city designs, icons, flags and tribe colours, opening graphic, to name but a few graphical elements are not touched. Other aspects such as Wonder and city improvement names likewise are unaltered. While one customised tribe has been added, there is scope to build on this by changing more if not all of the tribes. No events file is included for the scenarios. 
  

CONCLUDING COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS: On the positive side, the author has; 

- developed a package that does endeavour to embrace a new concept and offer new types of units, 
- created a workable technology tree with some good twists, 
- albeit the graphics are mostly borrowed, created a landform that's appearance is quite different, and 
- implemented small changes 'here and there' that integrate into the game quite well (e.g. irrigating forests create swamps not plains).  

One cannot help but be left with the feeling that this package is a work-in-progress, with many possibilities by-passed that could build a more compelling atmosphere. The feel of the default game carries through markedly when playing Aftergun. 

There is not much in the way of 'scene setting' in terms of the package delivering a scenario, while as a mod-pack there are still many elements that require some attention before this game will begin to take on a distinct and different experience. 

This work would be bolstered by support documentation, more original contributions, and if a scenario — plot establishment and definition. 
 

 
NOTES: This has been reviewed primarily as a 'scenario' more so than a 'modpack' / 'patch'.
 

HTML Design by Blackclove and Monk

Back to Fictional Scenario Reviews