League Watermark

League Scenario Reviews:
October to December 1998

This section lists ALL scenarios reviewed in the 4th Quarter of 1998 in approximately reverse chronological order.

Scenarios By Date: Other Seasons

Oct to Dec 1998

Jan to Mar 1999

Apr to Jun 1999

Jul to Sept 1999

Oct to Dec 1999

Jan to Mar 2000

Want to be a scenario reviewer? Click here for more info

 

Scenario Information

 

Category

 

Score

 

Description

The "New" Germany [Dec]

Author: John Petroski
Reviewer: Andrew Hoekzema

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

27.5
8.5
9
10
Probably the most accurate WW2 Europe scenario I've seen to date. [More]

New Civ Modpack [Dec]

Author: LeMay
Reviewer: Blackclove

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

27
7
10
10
This is the first time I've seen a "new standard" Civilization rules set that not only worked, but blew me away. [More]

Hundred Years War [Dec]

Author: Gary
Reviewer: Andrew Hoekzema

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

23
9
6
8
A huge medieval slugfest incorporating all the major powers. [More]

Hundred Years War [Dec]

Author: Gary
Reviewer: Blackclove

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

22
8
6
7
Covers the 100 Years War, and features many of the major powers of the time in Europe. [More]

World of Charr [Dec]

Author: Erick Robinson
Reviewer: Cam Hills

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

20.5
7.5
7
6
Mythical kingdoms are threatened by a Serpent Goddess. [More]

Colonization [Dec]

Author: Gary
Reviewer: Andrew Hoekzema

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

12
5
2
6
Discovery Age scenario including the French, British, Spanish, and Dutch as the colonizing powers. [More]

Colonization [Dec]

Author: Gary
Reviewer: Blackclove

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

19
6
5
8
Colonize the new world as one of the European powers. [More]

Colonization [Dec]

Author: Gary
Reviewer: Cam Hills

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

20.5
6.5
8
6
European nations seek to dominate the newly found Americas from 1492 to 1800. [More]

Swampland II [Dec]

Author: Mr. Temba
Reviewer: Blackclove

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

20
3
8
9
A fantasy scenario where players take the role of lizard people in a giant swamp. [More]

Alba de America [Dec]

Author: Jesus Balsinde
Reviewer: Tatu Aphonen

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

25
9
10
9

It is the dawn of America, and the Spanish and Portuguese are ready to take the lands of natives. [More]

1884 (Version 7) [Nov]

Author: Matthias Pitz
Reviewer: El Khan

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

18
6
6
5
Around 1900, the European powers rumble over their colonial possessions. [More]

1884 (Version 7) [Nov]

Author: Matthias Pitz
Reviewer: Michael Dauman

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

15
6
4
5
Japan, America, and the European colonial powers try to carve up the globe in the late 19th century. [More]

Israeli Independence [Nov]

Author: Yahav Nussbaum
Reviewer: Blackclove

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

17
7
5
5
Israel fights for independence after World War II. [More]

Israeli Independence [Nov]

Author: Yahav Nussbaum
Reviewer: Cam Hills

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

22.5
8
9
5.5
A successful recreation of the Middle East conflicts during the 'Cold War' modern era and up to the present day. [More]

Afrika [Nov]

Author: Ricardo Logus
Reviewer: Mr. Temba

 Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

 22.5
8
9
5.5
None provided. [More]

Australian Civil War 1999 [Nov]

Author: Dracon
Reviewer: Cam Hills

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

14
4.5
5
4.5
Australian factions and Pacific neighbours clash in a modern yet uncivilised society. [More]

Australian Civil War 1999 [Nov]

Author: Dracon
Reviewer: Mr. Temba

 Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

 16
4
6
4
Australian Civil War by Dracon, set in Oceania, large map. [More]

Australian Civil War 1999 [Nov]

Author: Dracon
Reviewer: Blackclove

 Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

 16
5
7
4
In 1999, Australia self-destructs and a massive war begins. [More]

Australian Civil War 1999 [Nov]

Author: Dracon
Reviewer: El Khan

 Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

 21
6
5
8
A modern-time scenario featuring a civil war in
Australia, with a lot of 'humor' and the 1NP. [More]

Civilization's Fall [Nov]

Author: JBD (unknown)
Reviewer: Blackclove

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

11
3
3
4

Post-apocalypse: Your civilization rises from the ashes of Earth to reclaim the world. [More]

Gangster (v. 3.0) [Nov]

Author: Cam Hills
Reviewer: Blackclove

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

29
9
10
10

Take the role of a mob boss in a fictionalized 1920's America. [More]

Gangster (v. 3.0) [Nov]

Author: Cam Hills
Reviewer: Andrew Hoekzema

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

24
9
7
10

Rival mob families duke it out in North America while trying to keep the law off their backs. [More]

Europe 1650 [Nov]

Author: Markus Eklund
Reviewer: Cam Hills

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

17.5
3.5
8
6

Peace agreements begin to sever in 17th Century Europe. [More]

Final Fantasy [Nov]

Author: Unknown
Reviewer: SeanD

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

12
7
3
3

A normal Civ2 game starting in the Iron Age. The relation to Final Fantasy is only in the names and your imagination. [More]

Alba de America [Nov]

Author: Jesus Balsinde
Reviewer: Susumu Korokoto

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

30
10
10
10

Tales of the discovery and conquest of America by the Spanish and/or the Portuguese. [More]

Australian Civil War 1999 [Nov]

Author: Dracon
Reviewer: Tatu Aphonen

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

19
?
?
?
Australia is in state of South Parkish civil war. [More]

1650 [Nov]

Author: Markus Eklund
Reviewer: St. Leo

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

24
8
6
7
A historical scenario focusing on Europe during the time of Louis XIV. [More]

Back to Main Page