League Watermark

Fictional Scenario Reviews

Fictional scenarios are alternate histories that use realistic events to construct a plausible alternate world. All scenarios are given an overall rating (out of 30) as well as three other ratings (each out of 10) covering how much fun the scenario is to play, how much attention to detail is in the scenario, and the quality of the artwork and original thinking that go into the scenario. Full reviews are provided with the express purpose of aiding the author in building a better scenario, as well as helping visitors select a scenario that fits their own personal tastes.

Want to be a scenario reviewer? Click here for more info

 Scenario Information

Category

Score

 

Description

Arctic: 2045

Author: Ryan Caruso (WarVoid)
Reviewer: Cam Hills

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

20
7
6.5
6.5

Modern nations fight for control of the arctic - an expanse rich with resources in an overpopulated world. [More]

Australian Civil War: 1999
Version 2.0

Author: Dracon
Reviewer: Mike Jeszenka

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

16
4
7
5

Update of Australian Civil War: 1999. Modern day scenario with a twist of sick humor. [More]

Australian Civil War 1999
Version 1.0

Author: Dracon
Reviewer: Cam Hills

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

14
4.5
5
4.5
Australian factions and Pacific neighbours clash in a modern yet uncivilised society. [More]

Australian Civil War 1999
Version 1.0

Author: Dracon
Reviewer: Mr. Temba

 Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

 16
4
6
4
Australian Civil War by Dracon, set in Oceania, large map. [More]

Australian Civil War 1999
Version 1.0

Author: Dracon
Reviewer: Blackclove

 Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

 16
5
7
4
In 1999, Australia self-destructs and a massive war begins. [More]

Australian Civil War 1999
Version 1.0

Author: Dracon
Reviewer: Tatu Aphonen

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

19
?
?
?
Australia is in state of South Parkish civil war. [More]

Australian Civil War 1999
Version 1.0

Author: Dracon
Reviewer: El Khan

 Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

 21
6
5
8
A modern-time scenario featuring a civil war in
Australia, with a lot of 'humor' and the 1NP. [More]

Civil War in San Lorenzo

Author: Taylor Harris
Reviewer: WarVoid

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

10
5
2
3

Marxist guerillas fight to liberate the fictional nation of San Lorenzo. [More]

Civil War in San Lorenzo

Author: Taylor Harris
Reviewer: Paul Hanson

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

13
5
4
4

Che Guevarra leads a revolution in a fictional Latin American nation. [More]

Europe: 2020

Author: Colon
Reviewer: Julia Sasson

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

13
4
4
5
Europe gets split into a bunch of megastates and they have at it in the near future. [More]

Europe: 2020

Author: Colon
Reviewer: Cam Hills

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

16.5
4
6.5
6
Europe divides following the collapse of the ineffective Union in the near future. [More]

Mysterious Cities of Gold

Author: François Baire
Reviewer: T. Allison

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

20
4
6
8

Cartoonish, fun scenario set in 1400's America and featuring the Olmecs. [More]

New Civ Modpack

Author: LeMay
Reviewer: Blackclove

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

27
7
10
10
This is the first time I've seen a "new standard" Civilization rules set that not only worked, but blew me away. [More]

Northern Ireland

Author: Ian Thompson
Reviewer: Cam Hills

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

18.5
8
4.5
6

Northern Ireland fractures in to full-blown conflict in the early 21st century. [More]

Northern Ireland

Author: Ian Thompson
Reviewer: Dan Silverwing

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

16
6
6
4

All-out civil war in Ireland between nationalist and loyalist forces. [More]

Rising of the Celts

Author: Jason Sorens
Reviewer: Kevin "DarthVeda" Chulski

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

7
1.5
4.5
1

The year is 2012 and the British Isles are embroiled in a civil war. [More]

Roman Riots

Author: St. Leo
Reviewer: Cam Hills

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

21


6.5
7
7.5

Roman legionnaires and cavalry combat a well-equipped town uprising. [More]

Second English Civil War

Author: Thomas Maunder
Reviewer: William Keenan

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

6
3
1
2

A near-future civil war takes place in England on an all-grassland map. [More]

(What If?) Cold War

Author: Unknown
Reviewer: Julia Sasson

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

9
4
3
2

The Soviets defeated the Germans in World War II, alone; now they are bent on world conquest. [More]

World War III/98

Author: Mark Laanen
Reviewer: Blackclove

Overall
Playability
General Care
Art/Originality

7
2
3
2

World War III breaks out after the U.S. and Britain bomb alleged terrorist camps. [More]

Back to Main Page